Aikido Hatenkai Core Concept: Regarding the 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹ - Zenith of Skill and Composure
By Fujisaki Tenkei, Head Instructor, Aikido Hatenkai
Table of Contents
Introduction: A New Guideline Presented by Hatenkai
Why is the 'State of Mastery' Necessary?: Establishing the "Backbone" of Hatenkai
What is the 'State of Mastery'?: Definition and Three Requirements
Attainment Levels of the 'State of Mastery': Step-by-Step Goal Setting
Specific Examples of the Strict State of Mastery (Instantaneous to within 10 seconds) (Case of Kotegaeshi²)
Examples Considered Included/Not Included in the State of Mastery
Why Pursue "Speed"?: Practical Reasons and Self-Growth
Core Technique 'Flowing Standing Joint Locks' (Ruten suru Tachi Kansetsu³): Practical Technique Responding to Change
Spirituality: The 'State of Mastery', 'Harmony' (Wagō⁴), and 'Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi⁵'
The Uniqueness of Hatenkai: Balancing Philosophy and Practical Effectiveness
Conclusion: The Evolution and Path of Aikido Presented by Hatenkai
Glossary
Introduction: A New Guideline Presented by Hatenkai
Aikido Hatenkai continues its daily quest, aiming for a fusion of practical combative strength and the profound philosophy of Aikido. We have now proposed the concept of the 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹ as a concrete guideline for our association and as the ultimate technical and spiritual goal.
This article will explain in detail the background behind advocating this 'State of Mastery', its specific content, and the path Hatenkai aims to follow.
Why is the 'State of Mastery' Necessary?: Establishing the "Backbone" of Hatenkai
Until now, Hatenkai has engaged in diverse training, ranging from traditional kata⁶ practice to various forms of kumite⁷ and match formats (such as Unified Aikido Rules, Aikido randori⁸ matches), handling strikes, combination techniques, and counters.
However, despite this rich training system, a unified, clear guideline regarding the ultimate level to aim for or the skills to be acquired was not necessarily presented.
It is in this context that the 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹ was proposed. This represents the ultimate state envisioned beyond the pursuit of deepening technique and spirituality within Hatenkai. Its purpose is to provide a consistent direction, essentially a 'backbone' running through the entire organization, to what was a diverse training system.
This concept is something I have deeply analyzed, systematized, and verbalized based on my own many years of practical experience in matches and sparring, and the high-level state that actually manifests during serious confrontations.
The word "state" (kyōchi) might sound abstract or unscientific, but this is not an unattainable idealism. We believe it can be achieved step-by-step through long and rigorous training. Precisely because the path is not easy and requires deep practice, we express it not merely as a "goal" but as an ultimate attainment point – a "state" (kyōchi).
What is the 'State of Mastery'?: Definition and Three Requirements
Defining the 'State of Mastery'
The 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹ is a technical system that deeply integrates and coordinates three key elements to calmly and reliably control an opponent. It also represents a martial arts state of being accompanied by high spirituality.
Advanced Aiki Techniques: The core of Aikido, utilizing the opponent's power, moving with the flow, and controlling the center.
Refined Throwing Techniques: Effectively throwing an opponent whose balance has been broken by Aiki.
Effective Striking Techniques: Strikes used to manage an opponent's attacks, create openings, or assist in control with minimal force.
The most crucial requirement in executing these techniques is 'Consideration for the Opponent' (Aite e no Hairyo). What Hatenkai aims for is not mere victory or the opponent's destruction. It is to reliably control the opponent without causing unnecessary pain or serious injury, even in severe circumstances. This ethical consideration is an indispensable element of the 'State of Mastery', defined by concrete requirements like the time needed for control, the state to be achieved, and "Consideration for the Opponent."
Attainment Levels of the 'State of Mastery'
The 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹ can be understood in stages based on the level of achievement, a consideration designed to keep practitioners motivated by setting feasible goals.
Strict Definition of the State of Mastery:
Goal: Complete control from instantaneous up to within 10 seconds.
State: An extremely high level of technique and mental state where the opponent has no chance to resist, and the situation is instantly brought under control.
Standard State of Mastery:
Goal: Complete control within 10 to 30 seconds.
State: The opponent's resistance is quickly contained, leadership is swiftly seized, and control is achieved. (In my personal feeling, even 30 seconds can feel like "it took a bit long.")
Broad Definition of the State of Mastery:
Situation: Cases where the opponent is a highly skilled martial artist, potentially exceeding the times above.
State: The opponent's resistance is ultimately and completely neutralized and controlled in a meaningful way.
Specific Examples of the Strict State of Mastery (Instantaneous to within 10 seconds)
Here are several scenarios demonstrating the application of Kotegaeshi² within the "Strict" definition:
Against a one-two punch combination: Handle the punches and, within that flow, immediately transition to Kotegaeshi to control.
When grabbed: Disrupt the opponent's posture with a strike to their central axis and control with Kotegaeshi before they can recover.
Against a kick: Handle the kick, divert their attention with a shutō⁹ (hand-edge strike) to the face, exploit the opening, apply hiji shime¹⁰ (elbow control) → if the opponent resists by pulling their arm → control with Kotegaeshi.
Making the opponent block a strike: Have the opponent block a shutō to the face, exploit the opening created by their defense, break their balance with ikkyō osae¹¹ → control the broken posture with Kotegaeshi.
Against a gyaku zuki¹² (reverse punch): After handling the punch, stop their movement with effective consecutive strikes, see an opening, and control with Kotegaeshi.
From a gedan geri¹³ (low kick): Unbalance the opponent with a low kick, quickly step in, and control with Kotegaeshi.
A Note on the 'State of Mastery': Actions that inflict excessive injury or unnecessary pain deviate from the definition, especially the requirement of 'Consideration for the Opponent'.
Examples Included/Not Included in the State of Mastery
Cases Included: After disrupting the opponent's posture with an Aikido technique, using minimal and effective strikes (not causing excessive damage) intended to make them lose their fighting spirit, leading to swift control. The strikes function as the "finishing touch."
Cases Not Included: After an Aikido technique, applying excessive strikes that could cause serious injury (violates 'Consideration for the Opponent'). Also, cases where the Aikido element is insufficient and control is primarily attempted through the power of strikes (deviates from Aikido's philosophy).
Why Pursue "Speed"?: Practical Reasons and Self-Growth
Why is "speed" emphasized in the 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)¹, particularly at the "Strict" and "Standard" levels? There are two main reasons for this.
1. Practical Reasons: Risk Reduction and Safety Assurance
In realistic self-defense situations, the longer a confrontation lasts, the higher the unpredictable risks become (third-party intervention, weapon use, escalating injuries). Bringing a situation under control safely and reliably in the shortest possible time is crucial for the practicality and safety of the martial art.
2. Process of Self-Growth: Practicing *'Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi'*⁵
After ensuring practical effectiveness, further pursuing "speed" is an important process for polishing the mind and technique to a high level, fostering self-growth. This connects to the Aikido philosophy of 'Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi'.
Speed is proof of "Correct Movement" (Masakatsu): True speed in martial arts comes not from brute force, but from the pursuit of efficient, waste-free movement that aligns with the body's mechanics. Aiming for speed polishes the accuracy and rationality of one's technique.
Speed is training in "Self-Control" (Agatsu): Moving quickly yet accurately in high-pressure situations requires calmness, concentration, and unwavering decisiveness. This is the "state of controlling oneself" (Agatsu). The challenge of speed becomes practical training for mental strength.
Speed is approaching the "Ideal State" (Katsu hayahi): The ideal state is natural, fluid, and transcends conflict. Aiming to move "more efficiently, more effectively, more swiftly" is the path to this state.
Thus, the emphasis on "speed" in Hatenkai is not just for practical effectiveness but also as a means to train the mind (Agatsu), polish technique (Masakatsu), and grow towards a higher state (Katsu hayahi). Speed is an indicator that manifests from a highly polished mind and technique.
Core Technique: 'Flowing Standing Joint Locks'
The core technical system for achieving the 'State of Mastery' is 'Flowing Standing Joint Locks' (Ruten suru Tachi Kansetsu)³. This practical art gives form to the Aikido concept of **'Takemusu Aiki'**¹⁴ (the creative adaptability to generate infinite techniques).
Its greatest feature is its ability to respond instantly to an opponent's changing movements, linking multiple standing joint locks seamlessly like flowing water to break their balance and achieve control. It aims to respond flexibly without rigidly adhering to fixed kata. For example, when an opponent grabs your wrist, you can instantly adapt the technique to their elbow, and then to their shoulder, linking them according to their reaction. With proficiency, it becomes possible to link three, four, or even more techniques to effectively bring an opponent under control without giving them openings to counter. This unpredictable "flow" (ruten) is the key to advanced control.
Technical Integration: Forming Foundational Mastery
This stage is a crucial bridge, connecting individual techniques honed in 'Flowing Standing Joint Locks' to a more advanced 'State of Control.' We refine the ability to seamlessly link striking, throwing, and joint locks, and to adapt flexibly to changing situations. The focus is on cultivating the practical capacity to eliminate the "gaps" between techniques, allowing them to unfold as a single, continuous flow. This solidifies the technical foundation required for controlling an opponent.
Spirituality: 'State of Mastery', 'Harmony', and 'Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi'
The requirement of "Consideration for the Opponent" within the 'State of Mastery' signifies a spirituality that transcends mere technique. Hatenkai believes that this "reliable capability accompanied by consideration" truly embodies the Aikido ideal of **'Wagō' (Harmony)**⁴.
The attitude of not losing consideration for others, even in extreme situations, indicates high spirituality. It is not about overpowering an opponent by force, but preventing conflict beforehand or resolving it swiftly with minimal force. We believe true 'Wagō' emanates from within, backed by this capability. Solid capability and confidence generate the mental composure to avoid conflict.
As mentioned earlier, the pursuit of the 'State of Mastery', especially its "speed" and "accuracy," is the process of practicing the philosophy of 'Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi' (Overcome yourself, act correctly, and victory will come swiftly and naturally). Rigorous training aimed at speed polishes the mind (Agatsu), refines technique (Masakatsu), and is a rational path towards the ideal state (Katsu hayahi).
The Uniqueness of Hatenkai: Balancing Philosophy and Practical Effectiveness
While many Aikido schools emphasize spirituality or traditional kata, Hatenkai deeply respects Aikido's core philosophies (Takemusu Aiki, Wagō, Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi, etc.) while also thoroughly pursuing practical effectiveness. Its uniqueness lies in clearly presenting concrete goals (the 'State of Mastery'), technical systems ('Flowing Standing Joint Locks'), and venues for verification (kumite, matches).
This can be seen as Hatenkai Aikido's unique answer—the 'State of Mastery'¹—to the ideals pursued in other martial arts, such as *'Ichigeki Hissatsu'*¹⁵ (one strike, certain kill) or *'Jū yoku Gō o Seisu'*¹⁶ (softness overcomes hardness).
Conclusion: The Evolution and Path of Aikido Presented by Hatenkai
To develop Aikido's abstract philosophy of *'Takemusu Aiki'*¹⁴ into the concrete technique of 'Flowing Standing Joint Locks'³, and through refining it, aim for the technical and spiritual attainment point of the 'State of Mastery'¹. And beyond that, reach the ultimate ideal of 'Wagō'⁴. This is the training system of Aikido presented by Hatenkai, and it also encapsulates my personal view of martial arts.
Hatenkai's evolution is reflected in the changes to its practical rules. The transition from the 'Full Contact Aikido Rules' to the 'Unified Aikido Rules'¹⁷, which permitted face strikes with shutō, was an important step. The 'State of Mastery' proposed this time indicates that Hatenkai has entered a new stage of development, pursuing not only practical levels but also higher goals and philosophical aspects.
My wish is that we share this high goal of the 'State of Mastery', polish our mind, technique, and body through daily training, and grow together. I believe that beyond the daily training lies true 'Wagō', built upon inner fulfillment, and that this path leads to effective self-defense. I hope we can contribute together to the development of martial arts and the realization of a better society.
Glossary
State of Mastery (Shōaku no Kyōchi): (掌握の境地) The ultimate technical goal of Hatenkai. A martial art state that integrates advanced Aiki, throwing, and striking techniques, accompanied by consideration for the opponent, allowing for calm and reliable control.
Kotegaeshi: (小手返し) A fundamental Aikido wrist lock/throw technique.
Flowing Standing Joint Locks (Ruten suru Tachi Kansetsu): (流転する立ち関節) The core technical system for achieving the 'State of Mastery'. It embodies the Takemusu Aiki philosophy, involving the fluid linking of multiple standing joint locks.
Harmony (Wagō): (和合) An ideal spiritual state in Aikido of harmonizing with others and the universe. Hatenkai perceives true Wagō as possessing the capability, accompanied by consideration for the opponent, to prevent or swiftly resolve conflict.
Masakatsu Agatsu Katsu hayahi: (正勝吾勝勝速日) An important Aikido philosophy: correct victory (Masakatsu), victory over oneself (Agatsu), and swift victory (Katsu hayahi). Hatenkai interprets the pursuit of speed as a practical way to embody this ideal.
Kata: (型) Pre-arranged forms or patterns of movement.
Kumite: (組手) Sparring or partner practice.
Randori: (乱取り) Free-style practice.
Shutō: (手刀) Hand-edge strike.
Hiji shime: (肘締め) Elbow lock or control.
Ikkyō osae: (一教抑え) "First teaching" pin or control.
Gyaku zuki: (逆突き) Reverse punch.
Gedan geri: (下段蹴り) Low kick.
Takemusu Aiki: (武産合気) An Aikido philosophy emphasizing the spontaneous generation of martial techniques.
Ichigeki Hissatsu: (一撃必殺) "One strike, certain kill."
Jū yoku Gō o Seisu: (柔よく剛を制す) "Softness overcomes hardness."
Unified Aikido Rules: (ユニファイド合気道ルール) Adopted by Hatenkai from 2019, these rules permit techniques like shutō strikes to the face, aiming to deepen technical effectiveness.
Ganseki Otoshi: (岩石落とし) Literally "rock drop." A specific striking technique.
Ushiro kubi shime: (後ろ首締め) Rear neck choke or hold.
A Note on Translation
"Isn't there a difference in nuance between '掌握の境地' (Shōaku no Kyōchi)?"
The accurate translation for '掌握の境地' is 'Zenith of Skill and Composure'. Please consider this to be the correct translation.
Part 1: Getting to Know Hatenkai Aikido Easily
For beginners and the general public. Starting with "What is Aikido?"
Q1. Isn't Aikido a martial art where you don't fight? So why do you have matches?A1. That's right, the ideal is to "resolve things without fighting." But sometimes, you have to stop someone. Matches aren't about becoming strong in a fight, but "practice in stopping someone's movement precisely without injuring them." It's training to develop power for when it's really needed.
Q2. The 'State of Mastery' (Shōaku no Kyōchi) sounds difficult...?A2. Simply put, it means "an amazing state where you completely understand the opponent's movements, use minimal force, don't hurt them, and have them perfectly under control." It's the goal we're aiming for.
Q3. Isn't just doing kata (forms) enough?A3. Kata are the important basics, like recipes in cooking. But just looking at recipes doesn't guarantee you can make delicious food. It's important to actually try cooking (matches and practice) to see if it works. Both are necessary.
Q4. Moving quickly doesn't seem very Aikido-like?A4. It's not just about being fast. It's about being calm in your mind and having no wasted movement, so you naturally end up moving quickly. Because there's no hesitation, you can move smoothly.
Q5. So, what is Hatenkai ultimately aiming for?A5. While cherishing the good parts of traditional Aikido, it's about "acquiring the ability to smartly resolve situations when you're in trouble, without hurting yourself or the opponent!" We're aiming for a martial art that is both strong and kind.
Part 2: For Those Who Want to Know More Deeply
Gentle explanations based on reasoning about Aikido philosophy and differences from other styles.
Q6. How is it different from other Aikido styles?A6. Other styles are wonderful too, but Hatenkai's style is "not relying solely on kata, but actually moving and verifying." We aim for "Aikido that can really be used" by confirming the effectiveness of techniques through matches and partner practice.
Q7. Is it really possible to "stop someone without injuring them"?A7. It's not easy, but we practice to become able to do it. The key is not brute force, but the ingenuity to "read the opponent's movement ahead and stop them with minimal force."
Q8. How do you acquire the 'State of Mastery'?A8. First, by carefully observing the opponent and learning how to break their balance (kuzushi) and manage distance (maai). Then, by internalizing the flow of joint locks and balance-breaking. Finally, by also training your sensitivity to "presence" (kehai) and "breath timing" (kokyū), you can gradually get closer.
Q9. You say "speed" is important, but is that the essence of Aikido?A9. The speed in Aikido isn't for competition, but "speed that comes from efficiency." When your mind and body are aligned, your movements naturally become refined and faster, so it doesn't contradict the essence.
Q10. Are "matches" and "striking practice" necessary in Aikido?A10. To know "how to respond to an opponent who is actually moving," they are very important. While acquiring practical effectiveness, they are intended more as a means "to apply techniques better" rather than "competing for wins and losses."
Part 3: Thinking Aikido – Bridging Philosophy and Practice
For those considering the future of Aikido, connecting mind, technique, and body.
Q11. Isn't there a contradiction between 'Wagō' (Harmony) and "controlling power"?A11. Wagō means "creating harmony without forced conflict." The ability to control is one means to achieve that. If you think of it as "a technique to quickly end a situation to prevent useless violence," it can be compatible with Wagō.
Q12. Should Aikido become competitive?A12. Hatenkai believes that "a place for technical verification and experiencing pressure" is necessary. However, we emphasize matches not as prioritizing winning or losing, but as "a place to test and mutually improve."
Q13. Is it really useful in a real fight?A13. To be immediately useful, we incorporate practice for dealing with multiple opponents and responding to strikes. However, we equally value the mental preparedness to avoid trouble in the first place.
Q14. Isn't the 'State of Mastery' just an idealism?A14. Even if complete attainment is difficult, "aiming" for it allows for significant growth in both technique and spirit. The attitude of "approaching the ideal" while responding to real challenges is the essence of martial arts training (shugyō).
Q15. How does Hatenkai balance "strength" and "kindness"?A15. Strength is the "power to protect," and kindness is the "heart not to injure." By acquiring not the power to defeat an opponent, but the "power to manage without having to defeat them," achieving both becomes possible.
Part 4: Deeper Explanation – The State of Mastery and its Martial Philosophy
Q1. Is the 'State of Mastery' merely a control technique?A1. No, it fundamentally differs from control by force. It is an ideal state of instantaneously grasping the opponent's movements, intentions, and reactions, and responding naturally without waste, thereby controlling them without relying on strength or speed and without causing harm. It is the pinnacle of technique, connected to mental calmness and ethics.
Q2. Doesn't this contradict the traditional Aikido emphasis on 'Wagō' (Harmony)?A2. It does not. The 'State of Mastery' is an attempt to embody the philosophy of Wagō as realistic technique. Wagō is not just avoiding conflict, but also receiving the opponent's force without resistance and resolving the situation without collision.
Q3. Then why does Hatenkai emphasize matches and verification?A3. Merely talking about ideals does not cultivate the power to respond to reality. Match-format practice is not for competing over wins and losses, but a place for self-verification: "How calmly, efficiently, and non-destructively can I control the situation?"
Q4. Is emphasizing "speed" correct from an Aikido perspective?A4. The speed in Aikido is not the "speed of haste," but the "speed of non-hesitation." In the 'State of Mastery', because one moves by reading the opponent's intention, actions that anticipate them naturally become fast. This speed connects to the concept of 'Katsu hayahi' (swift victory), representing speed that possesses deep spirituality.
Q5. Is Hatenkai's approach a denial of traditional Aikido?A5. It is not a denial. It is a reinterpretation seeking to understand traditional philosophies more deeply and apply them in a modern environment. Hatenkai respects the core of traditional Aikido while searching for a path that serves as a "bridge" between technique and ethics, ideals and reality.
Part 5: For You, Taking the First Step
Q1. I want to try Aikido, but I'm worried if I can do it.A1. It's okay. Aikido is a path to face yourself and move with a calm mind. A major appeal is that you can learn at your own pace, regardless of age or physical fitness.
Q2. What kind of atmosphere does the Hatenkai dojo have?A2. Hatenkai is a dojo aiming for "strong and kind Aikido." We practice techniques diligently but cherish an environment where you can improve in an atmosphere where "it's safe to fail."
Q3. What kind of person is suited for Aikido?A3. At first glance, one might think "people good at sports," but actually, "people who can listen calmly" and "people who can persevere steadily" are suited for Aikido. Anyone with respect for themselves and others is very welcome.
Q4. Is it okay if I'm not confident in my physical strength?A4. No problem. In Aikido, we value "movement without straining." Techniques are decided not by strength, but by body usage, balance, and breath (kokyū), so relying less on physical strength brings you closer to Aikido-like movement.
Q5. What kind of future awaits?A5. Through Aikido, you will gain confidence in your mind and body. Becoming able to act calmly and be considerate of others is a power that is very useful in daily life. Aikido training is a journey of self-cultivation. Won't you join us in starting this walk together?